Mon Nov 16, 2009 8:39 pm by JoshHechinger
I feel like "serious" is asking for something like "two plumbers (who're hinted to have mob connections) are sucked through a drainpipe into a surreal fungal feudal kingdom, where they stomp every mushroom motherfrigger standing between them and the princess who can get them home".
Which is not a million miles away from the movie, minus the dinosaur angle. So, I'm not sure it's possible to Pluto-ize Super Mario Bros.
That said...
Is it possible to do a Super Mario comic with sincerity, as an adventure story? Sure; honestly, all you'd need to do as a writer is keep the jolly adventure of the games, but underlay it with the fact that it's a love story (look at what this unassuming plumber is willing to dare for the girl he loves) or the theme of on-the-spot altruism (the Bros. get sucked into this frankly goddamn weird world, and without hesitation become heroes for a people who're not even remotely like them, because it's the right thing to do).
Put another way: Super Mario Bros. played straight is really just Adam Strange with plumbers and mushrooms.